Is Google Analytics really as good as other tools?

Well, this is a blog about web analytics, so I guess a web analytics type post is in order.

Since Google Analytics came out last year, there has always been a question:

Isn’t Google Analytics just as good as other web analytics tools that cost more?

And while there are many different answers to that question, I ran across something today which inspired a closer analysis.

When looking at keyword reports in Google Analytics you can view the search phrases

Google Analytics search phrases report

Or You can view the Search Engines

Google Analytics search engines report

But you can’t view both at the same time. In other words, You can’t see a report that displays all the search engines and their underlying search phrases simultaneously and vice versa. In addition the export function only grabs what is on the screen, so there is no correlation of those two data points in any exported report.

Briefly, I want to describe why it might be useful to see search engines by search phrases or vice versa. Let’s say that I am trying to optimize my site for the phrases, “wowza”, “yowza”, and “gyoza”. Wouldn’t it be useful to be able to track the number of referrals I got from Google and Yahoo over time without having to expand and collapse multiple boxes within the report? But it doesn’t appear that that is the case with Google Analytics.

The lack of this feature makes Google Analytics inferior to the likes of WebTrends, Omniture, Coremetrics, and WebSideStory. Although there is still no beating the price.
BTW, I would be happy to be wrong, so if you know some way to accomplish this in Google Analytics then please let me know, and I will obviously post an update.

Share with the world:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • YahooMyWeb

Comments (3) to “Is Google Analytics really as good as other tools?”

  1. I was in midst of a LONG answer (comment) to your post here and decided to add some images to my response – and not really knowing whether your blog supported it - I moved the comment to my own blog. :)

    http://visualrevenue.com/blog/2007/03/is-google-analytics-really-as-good-as.html

    The conclusion, however; is this:

    So: “Is Google Analytics really as good as other tools?” - The answer is No. Not because of the above of course, but the tool has technical limits in regards to customization that most enterprise clients not want, but need to carry out their analysis. However; my question would not so much be, whether it is as good, but whether the tool of choice solved the problem at hand – and for a lot of people, Google Analytics does and for that reason I think it is a splendid tool that I can only highly recommend. And with Avinash beginning to advocate Google Analytics as a consultant, I might as well just surrender now.. :-)

    Cheers

    Dennis, COO IndexTools
    http://indextools.com

    My Analytics Blog
    http://visualrevenue.com/blog

  2. […] Put all organic search engine reporting together. I have already blogged about this, and it is annoying. POST: Is Google really as good as other tools […]

  3. […] is the question Michael Helbling ask over at his excellent Web Analytics Blog – and not a bad question at all. But before voicing my opinion, let’s try to have a look at the […]

Post a Comment
*Required
*Required (Never published)